The U.S. China Trade War and the Crisis of WTO Dispute Settlement: Structural Failures, the 2025 Escalation and a Seven-Point Reform Agenda

Authors

  • Sheikh Muhammad Adnan Department of Law University of Southern Punjab Multan, Pakistan
  • Mohsin Raza Department of Law University of Southern Punjab Multan, Pakistan

Keywords:

WTO, U.S.–China Trade War, Dispute Settlement, Appellate Body Crisis, National Security Exceptions, GATT Article XXI, Multilateral Trade Governance, WTO Reform

Abstract

This analysis focuses on the most basic structural flaws in the WTO dispute settlement mechanism that have been revealed through the trade war between the U.S. and China. Based on a qualitative doctrinal analysis and a case-study approach of six WTO cases (DS543, DS544, DS565, DS489, DS501 and DS592), the article shows that the Appellate Body, paralyzed by the systematic U.S. veto of judicial appointments, has left a space for both parties to fill by selective compliance, retaliatory unilateralism, and the broad use of GATT Article XXI's national security exception. The article also conducts a qualitative analysis of the Trump administration's return to the 2025 escalation, which includes 60 per cent of “blanket” tariffs, financial sanctions, and supply chain embargoes, effectively making multilateral dispute procedures impotent. In this context, the article proposes a seven-point reform agenda, namely the restoration of the Appellate Body, clarifying the exception for national security, creating a major-power dispute protocol, reform of the SCM Agreement for non-market economies, establishing a plurilateral decentralization mechanism, adding a mandatory compliance arbitration mechanism, and a new digital trade and industrial policy rulebook, all of which are designed to suit the political economy of WTO negotiations. The article also adds directly to the literature on institutional design of the WTO and great-power trade governance by systematically linking the legal case record with the escalation in 2025, which the literature on the WTO lacks.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17